Learner-centered Leaders Engage the Voice of the Learner

In episodes 3 and 4, we had the opportunity to learn about learner-centered environments and leadership at Alamo Heights Independent School District in Alamo Heights, TX. We spoke with superintendent, Dr. Kevin Brown, and assistant superintendent, Dr. Frank Alfaro in Episode 3. In Episode 4, we spoke with Erick Castillon, a graduate of Alamo.

Key Competency

It was clear from our conversation with Kevin and Frank that learner-centered leaders engage the voice of the learner. We learned how Alamo Heights has created their Profile of a Learner and how students were involved extensively in this process. Learner-centered leaders treat learners as individuals, then design coursework that lays out a path to success aligned with the Profile. We heard this in Erick’s story.

Key Takeaways

Kevin and Frank spoke extensively on how they have focused on engagement. For quite a few years they have worked with the Schlecty Center to deepen their values around engagement. In order to design compelling learning environments where learners want to do the work, it’s important to understand the learners as individuals. This is done through learner panels and focus groups. Practicing close listening, qualitative data is gathered and used to design and redesign learning environments based on the individual needs and interests of learners.

This leadership stance goes beyond the classroom. Kevin and Frank shared that while initially the learner profile was focused on the classroom and listening to learners, they soon realized it applied to everyone in the organization. All stakeholders are valued as learners, engaged as learners and listened to as learners. This reminds us of an important component of design thinking – empathizing with the user. Design thinking is an important framework through which to deepen our understanding of learner-centered environments and leadership.

Along with gaining a deep understanding of stakeholders (learners) comes a flat organizational hierarchy. While there are formal titles, everyone is an individual with talents and strengths that can be tapped into when designing solutions to complex challenges. Everyone is a learner in the organization. Differences are valued as strengths.

Leaders in a learner-centered environment shape the conversations of the organization. At Alamo Heights, the conversation is focused on learning and the things they care about as communicated in the Profile of a Learner. Conversations around compliance occur (i.e. state accountability mechanisms), but they are overshadowed by conversations about learning and experiences for children.

Learner-centered leaders, through engaging stakeholders, have to learn to give up control to others. Building relationships requires vulnerability and an openness to letting ideas come from within the organization – this reinforces a culture of agency. Learner-centered leaders do not have all the answers.

At the classroom level, Erick’s story provides an example of engaged learning. Erick was successful in the rocketry program because it connected to his interests. He also shared that working on real-world projects was motivating, especially when he was expected to do most of the work of learning with support from his teacher as needed. The teacher provided the “what” for learning, but Erick was in control of the “how.” The classroom was a motivating and compelling environment for Erick because he needed to learn how to learn. That has served him well in two internships at NASA and in engineering coursework at the college level.

Time is used differently by learner-centered leaders. Kevin shared that leaders need to “get out where the game is being played.” This is a shift from traditional leadership paradigms where leaders spend much of the day in the office, behind a desk. Learner-centered leaders also make time to think and have enriching dialog around a vision for learning and how to translate that vision to reality. This often involves creating prototypes, gathering data and creating the next prototype rooted in the vision.

Connections to Our Practice

  • Listening to stakeholders – We seek out formative and summative feedback from a variety of stakeholders in the form of focus groups, surveys, conversations in professional learning sessions, coffee and conversation meeting, etc.
  • Our Profile of a Graduate has helped anchor our conversations around learning more frequently than before. Evidence of this is in the work with Leading #YourSalisbury.
  • Our organizational hierarchy in Salisbury is flat. As Kevin and Frank were describing what this looks like in Alamo Heights, we were making connections to what ours looks like.
  • We have also minimized the conversation outside of learning. While we complete tasks of compliance, we and our board do not hold them as the highest need. Those things that are valued most are indicated in our Profile of a Graduate.
  • We use our time differently than school-centered leaders. We are frequently out of the office and in our schools. We also engage each other in enriching dialog around vision and how to best translate that into reality. We are also learners – connecting with like-minded colleagues through state/national organizations, reading and producting two podcasts.

Questions Based on Our Context

  • How do we define enagagement? How do we use the engagement of learners to fuel change? How are our teachers, learners and students engaged?
  • How do we use feedback from stakeholders to redesign the map for change or redesign the next iteration?
  • Would a better understanding of the design thinking process deepen our understanding of the learner-centered paradigm?
  • What would it be like if we had more classrooms focused on real-world, authentic projects such as those described in these podcasts?
  • What if our leaders were more engaged in enriching dialog around learning? How can we better foster that?

Next Steps for Us

  • Engage in personal learning around engagement and design thinking.
  • Develop further opportunities to more deeply engage stakeholders in this work.
  • Determine how PBL can fuel our transformation and bring vision to reality.
  • Find formal and informal opportunities to engage our leaders (and all stakeholders) in conversations around learning (i.e. collaborative classroom walkthroughs, classroom spotlight segment on SFN-TV, community programs around the Profile of a Graduate on SFN-TV).

Episode 004 – Learning rocketry in a learner-centered environment Interview with Erick Castillon, graduate of Alamo Height Independent School District

In Episode 003, we learned about the work in Alamo Heights Independent School District with Dr. Kevin Brown (Superintendent) and Dr. Frank Alfaro (Assistant Superintendent). In this episode,  we had the chance to speak with Erick Castillon, a graduate of Alamo Heights and a former learner in its Rocketry Program for two years. Erick is currently a student at the University of Texas at San Antonio majoring in Mechanical Engineering. Erick has also had the opportunity to intern at NASA (Summer 2015 and Spring 2016). After listening to the podcast, check out the TEDx talk by Erick’s teacher, Colin Lang, to learn more about the amazing learning environment that transformed Erick!

After listening to this episode, you’ll want to ponder these questions:

  1. How might leaders provide opportunities for learners to develop their passions in a learner-centered environment?
  2. How do real-world projects support learner-centered education?

Resources

Episode 003 – Alamo Heights Independent School District Interview with Dr. Kevin Brown and Dr. Frank Alfaro

With episode 3, we begin our conversations with practitioners working to implement learner-centered education in schools. Our guests are Dr. Kevin Brown, Superintendent in the Alamo Heights Independent School District in TX and Dr. Frank Alfaro, Assistant Superintendent. Alamo Heights is a mid-urban district with about 4,800 students. Dr. Brown and Dr. Alfaro have led Alamo Heights to collaboratively develop the AHISD Profile of a Learner, which describes the characteristics and attributes we desire for our 21st century students.



These practitioners will inspire you to reflect on these and other questions:

  1. How might a learner profile help focus a school/district on being learner-centered?
  2. What takeaways from today’s conversation can you act upon in your own practice?

Resources:

How do you frame transformation?

This post is the first in a series connected to the podcast Shift Your Paradigm: from school-centered to learner-centered. My colleague, Lynn Fuini-Hetten, and I will be sharing our learning and thinking along the way and cross-posting to the Working At The Edge site.

In the first two episodes of Shift Your Paradigm, our guests (Kelly Young, Allan Cohen and Anya Smith) helped lay the foundation for future conversations by helping answer the questions: What is learner-centered? and What is learner-centered leadership?

One of my takeaways from the conversation was the importance of language and the words we use to describe our practice. In Episode 2, Allen helped clarify the idea of “transformation.” Allan piqued my curiosity and challenged my own thinking when he described transformation as a kind of change where the form of something is altered. Transformation occurs when we let go of the past and create something entirely new. It’s about breaking from what has been done, not just improving it. (Go ahead, read those last two sentences a few times and think deeply about how they resonate with your current thinking about change in education.)

You may be thinking about some of these questions: How are we transforming education? How is the paradigm shift from school-centered to learner-centered leveraged to bring about transformation in education? What is the evidence of a transformation? What are the learners (young and old) saying about the learning? The “how” of the paradigm shift and the transformation of education is what we will be focusing on starting in Episode 3. 

Once we’ve shifted our mindset, there is the actual work of transformation. And it is challenging! Leadership up and down the organization is critical, and we explored this topic in Episode 2 with Anya and Allan. Formal leaders working to transform learning first have to manage the dominance of the existing school-centered paradigm. Leaders can begin to cause something new to happen by introducing the new learner-centered lens into the culture of the school or district. Initially, they may sound crazy to those speaking the language of the dominant school-centered paradigm, and may not initially be heard because it’s disruptive to the dominant paradigm. Allan offered some valuable advice:  listen more than you speak. Find the best opportunities to share the new paradigm. Then ask the question, “What are your concerns? What are you curious about?” The shift – and subsequent transformation –  requires time, careful conversation and listening, not speeches. 

In Episode 1 Kelly offers this advice to leaders embarking on the transformation journey and the paradigm shift : (1) be a learner; (2) approach it as a mindset shift; (3) listen and find your own answers relevant to your own community; do not try to replicate what others are doing. “There is no one way to be!” What will you need to rethink in your context? What will you need to let go of? And in Episode 2, Anya reminds us that our greatest untapped resource in this work is our learners. How do we see everyone in the organization as a learner and a leader?

Ready for the work of transformation – breaking from what has been done and creating something entirely new? If you haven’t listened to Episode 1 and Episode 2, head on over to ShiftYourPardigm.org or iTunes and join us on the journey! Come back soon for Episodes 3 and 4 where we begin uncovering the “how” of transformation in specific contexts, speaking to leaders and a learner from Alamo Heights Independent School District in Alamo Heights, TX.

What is your vision for learning? What does it let go of from the past? What does it create that is entirely new?

Connect with Randy on Twitter and on the TLTalkRadio podcast!

Episode 002 – What is learner-centered leadership? Interview with Allan Cohen and Anya Smith

In episode 2, we speak with Allan Cohen and Anya Smith about learner-centered and learner-centered leadership. Allan leads transformational workshops for stakeholders addressing a wide range of social and economic challenges. He works with Education Reimagined as a strategic consultant and program leader. Anya is a learner at Mount Vernon Presbyterian School in Atlanta, GA, and serves as the Mount Vernon Institute for Innovation (MVIFI) Fellow as well as an inaugural Innovation Diploma member and graduate of the class of 2017.

After listening to this episode, you’ll want to ponder these questions:

  1. What AHA or clicking moments have you had along your leadership journey?
  2. How can we as leaders inspire our learners to make the world better?

Resources

Episode 001: What is learner-centered? Interview with Kelly Young, Executive Director, Education Reimagined

We are very excited to be partnering with Education Reimagined on this work and are pleased to kick off this podcast series with someone certainly expert in the learner-centered paradigm, Education Reimagined’s Executive Director, Kelly Young. In this episode, we lay the ground work for this podcast series by focusing the conversation on what learner-centered means and what learner-centered leadership might look like.

For each episode we leave you with a couple of questions to think about with the idea of provoking conversation. Leave your responses in the show notes! This episode’s questions:

  1. How would you explain learner-centered to a colleague?
  2. What is one practice you would like to re-examine as you make the shift to a learner-centered environment?

Resources